Dude09's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[A Breeze Of Reminiscence]

wow

are you the one who performed this piece? because it's beautiful. You have a truly debussy oriented taste, and i love it. It also reminds me of five for fighting a little bit. but it is beautiful. i should be done my next piece soon, so i'll update u on that. this piece is amazing, how u only have a 4.11 at the moment blows my mind. 5/5 and 10/10

Jabicho responds:

Yep, I performed it, had a lot of fun recording =), thanks for the amazing comment, hope to hear your next piece soon! =D

[An Empire of Dirt]

very pretty

It's very calm, and, well i guess "stationary" i like how u stay with one mood throughout the piece, and being able to compose a piece just from one moment of inspiration, thats pretty good, i love the piano part for this by the way. it almost to me sounded like a march of soldiers through a city that's already been attack and they witness the destruction around them, thanking god they weren't there when it happened. this song's melo and i love it :)

Tamadrum responds:

Thanks dude, It was such a peaceful day outside, I was just awe-struck with the beauty of it... I knew I had to write something then.

[Zero123Music >> Boss Battle]

wow

very very nice, i think that this is your best piece submitted within the month. it fits the mood perfectly. i'm sure even nobuo uematsu would be intrigued by this. i love the brass melody included too, it makes it extremely exhilarating, i love it :)

Zero123Music responds:

Thanks dude! (09) lol

This took a lot of work and all I need is a better brass sound.

This was made for the world r:2 MMO but the guy never PM'd back - oh well.
I'm still young :-)

thanks onece more

[You May Not Leave This PlaceV1]

hmm

You really love the cello don't you :) i think the melod could've been developed a bit more, but i'm a huge romantic fan, but i like the mood. if you can tell in my song (a hopeful heart) i'm a big fan of this sort of mood. I have no idea what happened at 0:53, maybe check that chord, it sounds diminished, maybe try a minor, it might make it smoother, but again, very peaceful, feels abandoned, forsaken, shit out of luck :) very nice

Zero123Music responds:

cheers a bunch, maybe check out V2.
It's not so much romantic but solitude, not so much not grabbing something but not being able to grab it.

I'm sorry but I liked that chord at 0:53 it was absolutely deliberate and I think you were thinking of the this as more of a love song which made the chord sound wrong.

Thanks for the 7!

[The Council (Strings)]

Very nice, very Baroque

I love the progression you used, a little longer would be great though. This sounds like something I'd hear in a Fire Emblem game. Also, great choice to have the cello play the melody, it really sets the mood, but i think you could've extended to be sort of a duet between the cellos and the violas, but thats just my opinion. I can definately see this in a video game, it's very peaceful. Great job!

Zero123Music responds:

Well, first thankyou very much for reviewing this.
Second I would love to do everything you just said like the duet and stuff but the program I used is bust.

And I made this when I was in my early 13 and with not much experience or knowledge of music.

[For Someone]

very nice

I love your style, and is this you performing it, if so, very well done, wish i could play that well instead of using a program to play my piece (a hopeful heart). This piece i can tell came from the heart, but if it didn't, i can only imagine what it would sound like, but its hard to do btr than this. very well done, a little longer would be nice though

Zero123Music responds:

not really me :-(

I'm downloading A Hopeful heart right now and will listen tonight :-)

Thanks for reviewin!

[Mac8 - Writhing Fixation]

wow

i'm a huge fan of dark/ gothic sounding music, and this song pretty much epitimizes and gives me a reason to love this style of music. My only complaint is that part with the tuba, i thought it sounded very out if place compared to the string and piano combination with some percussion. I know you were building up an augmented suspension to go into your finale, but i personally think a string base would do this peice more justice. beautifully written, dark, and i loved it, def. a fav. in fact, i'd be honored if you critiqued my piece, its dark, but long, but i think you would love it. please pm me if you send other amazing pieces like this in

SinJim responds:

Hey Dude (hah...), I'm glad you liked this one. The tuba is a bit odd in there and I definitely sat there for awhile trying to determine if I should include it or change it. I guess in the end I decided that because it was for Madness and it should have that theme, the tuba felt a bit out of place and put a sense of craziness into the song. Had I not been entering the competition, I most likely would have gone for the double basses, but who knows. If I do upload another version, I'll take your advice and consider the strings to see if it sounds better. Thanks for the comments!

~SinJim

[*What Have I Done? *]

very moving :)

as you could tell by my one song "a hopeful heart" i'm a sucker for this kind of music. it's full of emotion, i cant believe this wasnt inspired by an experience of yours, it just seems to speak to the heart. it also reminds me a lot of nobuo uematsu's "suteki da ne" (or however its spelled) which is definately a good thing. the only thing i wouldve liked to be included in the song is a definitive climax in the song, other wise its astounding, thanks for recommending me to listen to it :)

KTRECORDS responds:

Sweet, thx for checkin it out. I'm glad you like it. This was my first big solo song so I had to put a lot of TLC into it. I plan on redoing it someday with some better instruments. If that happens, then I made be able to add that climax that people have been looking for in the song.

Anyways, thx again for checkin it out. Check back for more songs from KTRECORDS

-Jason
KTRECORDS

[Crowley's Uniform]

its bullshit your so low

i cant believe they did this to you dude, i'll put you in my favs, you truly have great gift for composing, dont ever stop

TheMaskedJew responds:

It's fine. I learned long ago that there is a vast separation between compositional adequacy and popularity on Newgrounds.