Dude09's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Inamorata (collab III)]

Casual?

Casual sex huh? You have some interesting tastes dude if that's what you have sex to (have some glwsticks to?) Okay now to critiquing. I think you would do Benny Benassi proud. Very accelerating. Love all the sounds you use. Interesting take on the love theme too. So yeah. Very nice breakdown at 2:58. I'm very impressed at the middle to end. (What is the dude saying though?) Nice speed up, kinda like a climax I'm guessing? Nice second breakdown at 3:50. Nice ending too. This wasn't what I expected to hear as a judge, but I'm grateful I did %uF04A 5/5 10

[For You, a Thousand Times Over]

hmmm

Hmmmm . I'm on border hear, I hear no flaws, but it's very safe. A little bland. The piece seemed very predictable too. It seemed very bland. Sorry dude. 4/5 8.5/10

MusicalRocky responds:

Lol ok.

Although, bland and predictable would've perhaps been running a more expected chord progression with the main theme, having a B theme in the relative minor, and then bringing back the original melody in the home key with just a few changes and then resolving. All of which I tried to avoid.

[The Last Night [Extended]]

Peaceful, very serene.

Very nicely done string arrangement and composition. Very peaceful. I feel like I could fall asleep next to the one I love to this. It feels like I'm on the Titanic in Lord of the Rings (lol) I'm very impressed. I hear no flaws. 5/5 10/10

MusicalRocky responds:

Hahah word.

thanks for the review dude (lolpun)

-Rocky

[XS - The Little Note's Story]

YAY!!

I feel like I'm inside a SNES. Kinda short. Nice beat, but a little redundant until about 0:50. Very nicely done in a loop. 4/5 8.5/10

[XS - Novus Orsa]

NIce percussion

Drum set works very well in this piece. The main melody is pretty nice too. But I didn't feel the love need for this competition. Seems like the beginning of an action film honestly. Nice piano, but the snare did seem a bit off every once in awhile. Nice fade. Weird extra instrument at the last second. 4/5 8/10

[[\Under the Night Sky - Mac9/]]

????

That wind instrument (i'll call it a contra flute) sounded really raspey and off pitch. The jumps in the vocal was unorganized. The piano was okay. The 4/4 waltz is very appreciated. From 1:24 on it was great! until 2:35 ish. cut the vocal and weird wind in the beginning and it would be a ten easily. (Love the samba) the voice does not work well with the strings at about 4:30. overall 4/5 8/10

paradoxphenomena responds:

Well said; thank you for the useful comments you made. This piece could have done with a remake but sadly i don't have the time though I wholeheartedly agree with the jumps in vocals and the flute did need more work but time was of the essence and I should perhaps not have rushed it and polished it better. I'm glad you took the time to listen to it and review it as you did.

[Flawless Love - Mjattie]

its so hard not to seem biased

Beautiful. The trance mood with this lovely melody is so amazingly pure!! I want to fall in love to this song and have a glowstick at the same time!!! 1:24 was a chills moment. 1:53 nice breakdown. 2:31 something was a tad off. I know you were going for the chromatic buildup, but the rest of the chord should change too. THE PIANO ADDITION WAS GREAT!! 5/5 10/10

mjattie responds:

thanks :), Don't know what you mean with the chromatic buildup though.

[-Together- (Piano)]

wow

B-e-a-utiful. I can clearly sense the love. The occasional ornamentation is well placed. The chords worked well. I love the flowy harmony. The simple melody accents the pieces beauty. Catchy, which I love. Should be in FF series :D 5/5 10/10

[Rudy P. - She Said Yes (MAC9)]

hmmm

Good length. I was expecting more. It's very Herbie Hancock-ish (rockit) I can sense a celebration. Going on in here, but still, a little more emotion would've been nice. A few noices seemed out of place too, I would tell, but I don't know what to call that noise (like Mario going down a tube?) 3/5 7/10

Fuiste responds:

Eh, I kinda like that noise you're referring to. (It's a 3xosc, saw-saw-pulse) But I guess we'll agree to disagree. Still, I'm glad you liked the song, and I'm always grateful for reviews!

Peace.

[For Her (MAC9)]

daft punk would be proud

Very spacey, I think the percussion makes a very interesting beat. At about 1:10 an awkward chord appeared. Length is getting better. Loop is perfect. The love feeling in this though is hard to grasp for the v-day love theme. 4/5 8/10

nightsurfermusic responds:

Thank you good sir :)