Dude09's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Love, As I Know It (MAC9)]

in my opinion

your best piece. for 13 ur talent is fantastic. it seems like you know quite bit of theory already. this style and song would make debussy proud. you how a very promising career. i'm only 18, but i'm a member of ASCAP, and if I could do t with my songs, then i know you could easily become a member and potentially a huge inspiration in classical future. (please make longer though, i love it :) ) its wonderful in every sense. i know i'm not a fav of yours, but ur def. one of mine after this song. i could go on about how great it is, but i'll let my grades speak for themselves. 5/5 10/10

Zero123Music responds:

thanks alot dude :) - those grades are awesome! =D

[Romantic Impression - Mjattie]

wow

stunning me again. i love your style. (it's not what i would call a waltz). i love the synchopation. usually i dont like a single nte as a pedal tone, but it worked out very well in this case. Love the string part you put in, and what program do you use, cause the piano sounds brilliant. You should def. continue this piece and submit it to the mac09 competition. I'd be rooting for ya. This piece is one of my favs. I'd love to work with ya sometime maybe on a collaboration. 10/10 5/5

mjattie responds:

hey, the pianosamples are from reason piano's (it's an expansion from reason). So yea, I use reason... I'm glad you like my style :) and I definitely want to do a collab with you.

Gr Mjattie, and thanks!

[Autumn Wind]

amazing

THE PIANO IS AMAZING:) debussy, ravel, and chopin would be proud. The strings however, in my opinion, would cause vivaldi and paganini to be rolling around in their graves. Some moments with the strings woked really well. But the strings cracked and their notes were either off tune or just played badly. If it was just piano, I would give it a 10/10 easily. BUt in my opinion, the strings ruined it. so i figured 10/10 for composition, 10/10 for piano, 4/10 for strings, averages to an 8/10. Again, amazing job with the piano.

[Unattainable Freedom]

HOW THE HELL ARE YOU UNDER ME IN RANKS!!

i'm gonna do whatever it takes to get you up up UP!! i absolutely love the bass you put in, if this was longer i'm sure u could submit that as to being a masterpiece!! perfect submission!! 5/5 10/10 this song better be able mine soon!! the loop works perfectly btw :)

BlazingDragon responds:

Thanks Dude, that means a lot to me. Hopefully I'll have more out soon. :)

[Nocturne no. 1 - These Secrets]

great :)

you wont see me bitch about this, it sounds great :) i hope your girl loves it, causei do, i love what you did at 1:20 on! longer wouldve been nice though (sry had to bitch about something) lol :) 5/5 10/10 (+0.047)

Lamplighter responds:

Well, actually she's not mine... I wish. :) If only...

Thanks for the review, I always love the encouragement!

[34 Seconds in A Minor]

simple, maybe a bit too simple

i always hate being the lowest in the reviews :( u have a good concept, i see where youre getting at. a more elaborate bass line would help, such as making the individual note into chords instead of individually playing them out, and wtf happened with the end?? although all wtf's aside, for doing this in a short time, its pretty good, a little more elaboration could really make this fly though :) 7/10 4/10 for potential (+0.0091)

Lamplighter responds:

Being the lowest is fine, as long as you explain them. Now, it's my turn.

1. You say a more elaborate bassline... I say blocked chords would make it less elaborate. I can't really say I see what ya mean there.

2. Last chord... this was for a collab where this piece was to flow into the next one. I know the chord sounds off, but if this had looped better it would sound more connected.

I am going to come back and revisit this one when I make it into a full song.

[Church Choir]

I LOVE IT!!!

MY FAVORITE PIECE BY YOU!! I ABSOLUTELY LOVE IT, PLEASE PUT IT ON THE CLASSICAL SETTING!!! i dont think basses can go as low as you have them going, but i LOVE THAT FACT!!!! AMAZING BEAT AND RHYTHYM!! 5/5 10/10 (+0.072)

Assassin2 responds:

Lol thanks man. This was the first thing I made with Logic Pro 8 which I'm so happy I got. It was fun to make and good for a laugh. Thanks for the kindness.

[-Regret-]

lol suck less?

lemme see if i got your format correct, bass strings and cellos on same, snare everyonce in awhile with cymbal, second violins doing arpeggios, violas same as cellos, and a solo violin, and did i hear a siren? its good. my recommendation would be to not make it a solo, maybe only a solo in the beginning cause the melody i think repeats itself. make it a duet the second time, third time duet with harmony (while the arpeggios continue have the duet violin countermelody using counterpoint) accent more with cellos, they are beautiful instruments. then again these are just my opinions :) you have a great concept. if it was more developed it could be a spectazcular performance. 4/5 8/10 (i wont vote cause that'll decrease your score)

Assassin2 responds:

I love that you looked into it so much. In all honesty, this was my first song, and it was in FL studio and it became a real mess so I had to simplify it, it originally had the siren and battle sound effects and it was just, whack. The way you would have it is pretty much what I would want to, I really need to remake this once I get the know-how. Thanks for listening and talking about it.

[Lonely Butterfly]

not bad

i definately liked the other version better, i can see where your going with this, but i kinda saw it to the intro of a horror theme (like halloween's theme) it's def. good, high pitched maybe, but then again, i heard your other version first, so i'm a little biased. again, good job with this. 4/5 8/10 (+0.046)

Assassin2 responds:

I really appreciate the fact you actually review things and offer an opinion. I actually loved the Halloween theme, I can't see it in mine, but the pitch is similar. I might do a horror piece now. Thanks for reviewing friend.

[Lonely Butterfly v2]

nice

this would make the perfect intro, its so serene, so pure!! 5/5 10/10 (+0.36)

Assassin2 responds:

Thanks man, means a lot coming from you.